Disney's Snow White Remake Vs. The 1987 Horror Version: Unexpected Parallels

Henrik Larsen

4 min read

Post on May 14, 2025

4.4

Share

Shared Narrative Elements: A Foundation in Fairytales

Both Disney's Snow White remake and the 1987 horror version draw heavily from the core elements of the original Brothers Grimm fairy tale. This provides a foundational framework despite their contrasting styles. Both versions retain the central conflict: a beautiful princess, Snow White, threatened by an Evil Queen consumed by jealousy. The poisoned apple, the prince's arrival, and even the presence of seven dwarfs remain consistent plot points.

• Shared Plot Points: The poisoning, the escape to the dwarfs' cottage, the queen's attempts to kill Snow White, and the eventual rescue by the prince are all present in both versions.
• Contrasting Approaches: Disney's version emphasizes whimsical charm and musical numbers, softening the darker aspects of the original tale. The 1987 horror film, however, embraces the darker elements, creating a suspenseful and terrifying atmosphere. The queen's motivations, while stemming from jealousy in both, are explored with significantly more depth and complexity in the horror adaptation.
• Character Motivations: While the Evil Queen's vanity and desire for eternal youth are central in both, the horror film delves deeper into psychological motivations, exploring themes of obsession and madness absent from the Disney narrative.

Contrasting Interpretations of Key Characters: Heroine, Villain, and the Dwarfs

A significant difference lies in how the key characters are portrayed. This character analysis reveals the stark contrast between the two films' interpretations of the source material.

• Snow White: Disney's Snow White is portrayed as a passive, innocent damsel. The 1987 version, however, presents a more proactive Snow White, albeit still vulnerable to the Queen's machinations.
• The Evil Queen: In Disney's version, the Evil Queen is a melodramatic villain driven by vanity. The 1987 horror film explores a more nuanced and terrifying antagonist, fueled by a chilling blend of jealousy and psychotic rage. Her methods of villainy become significantly more brutal and disturbing. This difference is crucial to understanding the "Snow White portrayal" in each version.
• The Dwarfs: In Disney's film, the dwarfs are comedic relief. The 1987 horror version uses the dwarfs more sparingly, often casting them in a more sinister light, reflecting the overall darker tone of the film. The "dwarfs' roles" serve entirely different narrative functions.

Thematic Parallels: Exploring Darkness and Power

Despite their vastly different styles, both films explore similar underlying themes. A thematic analysis reveals surprising commonalities in their exploration of dark fairy tale themes.

• Jealousy and Envy: Both versions center on the Evil Queen's consuming jealousy of Snow White's beauty and youth. This remains a powerful driving force in both narratives.
• Power of Appearances and Deception: The Evil Queen's use of magic and disguise highlights the deceptive nature of appearances, a theme explored in both interpretations, albeit with different levels of subtlety.
• Struggle for Control and Dominance: The central conflict revolves around the Evil Queen's desperate attempt to maintain control and dominance, reflecting the timeless struggle for power found in many fairy tales.

Visual and Atmospheric Differences: A Tale of Two Worlds

The stylistic choices in each film create vastly different viewing experiences. A film analysis focusing on these differences highlights the contrasting approaches to storytelling.

• Color Palettes and Cinematography: Disney's remake utilizes vibrant, saturated colors and a bright, cheerful cinematography style. The 1987 horror film employs a darker, more desaturated palette and uses shadows and low lighting to create a suspenseful atmosphere.
• Music and Sound Design: Disney's version relies on enchanting musical numbers to enhance the fairytale atmosphere. The horror film utilizes a suspenseful, unsettling soundtrack to amplify the film's dark and terrifying tone.
• Overall Tone and Atmosphere: The Disney remake is whimsical and lighthearted. In contrast, the 1987 horror version creates a dark, suspenseful, and chilling atmosphere.

Conclusion: A Final Look at Disney's Snow White Remake and the 1987 Horror Version

In conclusion, Disney's Snow White remake and the 1987 horror version offer vastly different interpretations of the classic fairy tale. While their visual styles and overall tones differ dramatically, both share surprising parallels in narrative structure and thematic elements. The core conflict, character motivations, and underlying themes remain remarkably similar, showcasing the enduring power of the original story. Dive deeper into the world of Snow White by comparing these two wildly different adaptations – experience the magic of Disney's Snow White Remake and the chilling suspense of the 1987 horror version! Engage in Snow White movie comparisons to fully appreciate the range of interpretations this classic fairytale allows.