John Wick 4: A Critical Underdog? Examining Its Rotten Tomatoes Score And Audience Reception

Henrik Larsen

4 min read

Post on May 11, 2025

4.7

Share

Rotten Tomatoes Score: A Closer Look

As of October 26, 2023, John Wick: Chapter 4 boasts a 95% critics' score and a 98% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes. This near-perfect audience score immediately suggests a significant positive audience reaction, a stark contrast to some earlier entries in the franchise. Let's examine the nuances within these scores.

Critical Consensus:

The high critics' score reflects a generally positive critical response. While some critics acknowledged the film's over-the-top violence as a potential drawback, most lauded its many merits.

• Positive Critical Feedback:

  • Keanu Reeves's nuanced and compelling portrayal of John Wick.
  • Innovative and breathtaking action choreography that pushed the boundaries of the genre.
  • Stunning visuals and set design that enhanced the immersive cinematic experience.
  • The well-crafted and engaging storyline, even with its familiar action movie tropes.

• Common Criticisms (Minor):

  • Some critics felt the sheer volume of action, while impressive, occasionally overshadowed the narrative elements.
  • A few reviewers noted the film's predictable plot points within the established John Wick universe.

Methodology Matters:

It's crucial to remember that Rotten Tomatoes scores are aggregated from a specific group of critics and audience members. The methodology, while transparent, can still be subject to inherent biases and doesn't represent the opinion of every single viewer or critic. Relying solely on Rotten Tomatoes scores to gauge the overall quality of a film should always be approached with a degree of critical perspective. Considering other review aggregators and individual reviews provides a more comprehensive picture.

Audience Reception: Beyond the Tomatoes

The overwhelmingly positive audience score on Rotten Tomatoes (98%) is mirrored by similar high ratings on other platforms like IMDb. This suggests a strong connection between the film and its audience.

Positive Audience Feedback:

The enthusiastic audience reception stems from several key factors:

• Non-stop, exhilarating action: The film delivers on its promise of intense, meticulously choreographed fight sequences, leaving viewers breathless.
• A satisfying conclusion (to this chapter of the saga): Many viewers expressed satisfaction with the film's narrative arc and resolution, leaving them feeling emotionally fulfilled.
• Stylish cinematography and visual flair: The film's visual style is a major draw, with stylish cinematography and visually captivating fight sequences.
• Memorable fight scenes: Specific fights, like the iconic lengthy one-take shot sequence, have become instant classics among action movie fans.
• Strong emotional core: Beneath the surface of relentless action, the film explores themes of loyalty, revenge, and the weight of the past, resonating deeply with many viewers.

Addressing Negative Audience Reactions (if any):

While overwhelmingly positive, some audience members felt the film was excessively long (which is a common criticism of action epics). A few mentioned minor plot points that felt slightly contrived or predictable, but these criticisms were largely outweighed by the positive responses.

Box Office Performance:

The box office success of John Wick: Chapter 4 further solidifies its audience appeal. Its strong performance compared to previous installments in the franchise indicates a significant and dedicated viewership, demonstrating its ability to draw in both existing fans and new audiences.

The Critical Divide: Understanding the Discrepancy

While both critics and audiences largely enjoyed John Wick: Chapter 4, a slight gap in enthusiasm exists. This discrepancy can be attributed to several factors:

Genre Expectations:

Critics, sometimes looking for more profound narrative depth, might hold action films to a different standard than the general audience. Action movie purists and fans often prioritize the spectacle, making the near-perfect audience score unsurprising.

Different Priorities:

Critics may prioritize artistic merit, innovative filmmaking techniques, and originality, while audiences might value entertainment value, thrilling action, and emotional connection above all else.

The Cult Following Factor:

The John Wick franchise has cultivated a fiercely loyal fanbase. This dedicated following contributes significantly to the positive audience reception, as fans eagerly anticipated and celebrated the latest chapter in their beloved saga.

Conclusion

John Wick: Chapter 4 garnered near-perfect audience scores (98% on Rotten Tomatoes) and a very high critical score (95%), highlighting a largely positive reception from both critics and audiences. While minor criticisms emerged regarding the film’s length and some predictable plot points, these were largely overshadowed by the film's impressive action sequences, compelling narrative, and satisfying conclusion. Was John Wick 4 truly a critical underdog? While the critical acclaim wasn't quite as universal as the audience praise, the film clearly resonated with viewers and critics alike. The film's success stems from a perfect blend of high-octane action and an engaging storyline, appealing to both casual moviegoers and dedicated fans of the franchise.

Have you seen John Wick 4? What's your take on its Rotten Tomatoes score and overall audience reception? Share your thoughts in the comments below!