The Best John Wick Movie Has The Worst Rotten Tomatoes Score? A Critical Analysis

Henrik Larsen

5 min read

Post on May 11, 2025

4.9

Share

John Wick: Chapter 2's Rotten Tomatoes Score: A Statistical Anomaly

John Wick: Chapter 2 boasts a Rotten Tomatoes score of 89%, a respectable number by most standards. However, this figure falls short of the 90% score of the original John Wick and the 95% score of John Wick: Chapter 3 – Parabellum. This discrepancy is even more pronounced when considering audience scores. While critical consensus placed Chapter 2 slightly below its siblings, audience scores often rated it higher, revealing a significant divergence between critical and popular opinion.

• Rotten Tomatoes Scores:

  • John Wick: 86% (Critics), 94% (Audience)
  • John Wick: Chapter 2: 89% (Critics), 92% (Audience)
  • John Wick: Chapter 3 – Parabellum: 95% (Critics), 91% (Audience)
  • John Wick: Chapter 4: 95% (Critics), 96% (Audience)

• The lower critic score for Chapter 2 could be attributed to several factors: a perceived lack of the groundbreaking originality of the first film, some perceived flaws in the plot's intricacy, and perhaps even a case of "sophomore slump" expectations. Nevertheless, the audience clearly appreciated the advancements in action and world-building.

The Action and Gun-Fu: A Deeper Dive into Chapter 2's Strengths

Many fans consider John Wick: Chapter 2's action sequences superior to those in other installments. The film showcases a remarkable evolution of the signature "gun-fu" style, incorporating even more intricate choreography and innovative camera work. The practical effects and stunt work are breathtaking, creating a visceral and realistic action experience that sets a new standard.

• Memorable Action Scenes: The extended fight in the dimly lit Continental Hotel, the brutal car chase through Rome, and the final showdown are all frequently cited as highlights.
• Stunt Team and Directors: The film's success is largely due to the meticulous work of the stunt team and Chad Stahelski's visionary direction. The seamless blend of practical effects and CGI elevates the action to a new level.
• Expansion of the John Wick Universe: Chapter 2 significantly expands the world, introducing new factions, characters, and rules, enriching the action with complex stakes and interwoven narratives. This aspect alone greatly enhances the cinematic experience.
• Action Style Comparison: While other action franchises rely heavily on CGI, John Wick consistently prioritizes practical effects, creating a more grounded and impactful style.

Plot Complexity vs. Simplicity: A Balancing Act

Compared to the relatively straightforward plot of the first film, Chapter 2 introduces increased narrative complexity. The introduction of new characters like Cassian and the expansion of the High Table's intricate rules and consequences add layers of depth to the story. However, this added complexity might have contributed to some critics finding the film less immediately engaging than its predecessor.

• Key Plot Points: The introduction of the High Table and its rules, the complex relationship between John and Cassian, and the ramifications of John's past actions all significantly shape the narrative.
• Plot Structure Comparison: While the first film focuses on a simple revenge plot, Chapter 2 develops a more multifaceted narrative with numerous moving parts, demanding more attention from the audience.
• Impact of World-Building: The expanded world-building, while enhancing the overall universe, does add complexity that might not appeal to all viewers.
• Intricate Plot vs. Straightforward Action: The film successfully balances the intricate plot elements with the consistently exciting and visually stunning action sequences. However, critics might have perceived the plot complexity as overshadowing the visceral action.

Critical Reception vs. Audience Appreciation: A Case Study

The divergence between critical reviews and audience reactions highlights the subjective nature of film criticism. While some critics praised the action, others criticized the plot's complexity, finding it muddled or less engaging than the first film. This discrepancy emphasizes the importance of understanding the context and biases influencing critical reviews.

• Positive Critical Reviews: Many lauded the film's action, cinematography, and the expansion of the world.
• Negative Critical Reviews: Some critics felt the plot was convoluted and that the increased complexity detracted from the film's overall impact.
• Audience Feedback: Online forums like IMDb and Reddit generally showed a more positive response, with many fans citing the action and world-building as strengths.
• Influence of Marketing and Hype: The immense hype surrounding the franchise might have influenced both critical and audience reception.
• Personal Preference: Ultimately, the appreciation of a film often comes down to personal preferences. What one critic might view as a flaw, another might see as a strength.

Conclusion: The Best John Wick Movie Debate Continues

The lower Rotten Tomatoes score for John Wick: Chapter 2 remains a fascinating case study in the complexities of film criticism and audience reception. The film's undeniable strengths—its breathtaking action sequences, innovative stunt work, and expansion of the John Wick universe—are widely celebrated by fans. While some critics might have found fault with the plot’s increased intricacy, it undeniably cemented the film's place as a fan favorite. Ultimately, declaring the "best" John Wick movie is a subjective matter, highlighting the diverse and often contradictory nature of film appreciation. So, what's your take? Which John Wick movie reigns supreme in your opinion? Share your thoughts and join the ongoing debate on the best John Wick movie!